The Canon Powershot G9 - A User’s Review

I have always preferred a small camera to a large one. Yet I still find myself with 20 pounds of equipment on my back during long walks across sometimes wet and muddy paths in remote regions of the world. And just getting to such regions is often a nightmare with all the baggage restrictions one must consider when flying. Having a small camera that produces high quality images, is therefore a quest that I have pursued for some time.

When the Canon Powershot G9 was announced I grew excited about a 12 megapixel camera that weighed only 12 ounces and could fit in a shirt pocket. And I eagerly read several reviews of the camera made by professionals who understand digital camera technology far better than I do. Most of those reviews were mixed with pros and cons. But, being the stubborn person I am, simply reading what others have to say about any product won’t do, I have to use the product myself. It is an obsessive compulsive thing. I want the hands on experience.

So, I bought the Canon Powershot G9. Initially, my reason for the purchase was my forthcoming trip to Ecuador and the Galapagos Islands. My interest was primarily in doing underwater photography while snorkeling in the islands. I did not think that the G9 would be useful beyond that purpose. I was totally wrong.

Following the intense experience of shooting with the camera for three weeks, I thought perhaps a few words about the camera might be useful to others who are serious about buying a small camera for use not just as a travel camera, but one for general use at home, at school, or during special occasions. And, I thought it might be useful to provide some example photographs done with the camera so that others might see what the camera can do. If one is interested in technical stuff, the canon website provides detailed specifications for the camera here.

The first question I asked myself was: “Will the camera produce high quality images?” And the answer is yes. Here is one of my first shots taken near my home in Safety Harbor, Florida, just before sunrise.

img_0198.jpg

One might say that I was stunned by the quality of the image. Clarity was superb. Course I was shooting at ISO 80, and I was using a tripod, and I was really working to get the exposure correct. Given all that, I was still amazed at the images I shot that morning.

But the truth is, in most instances, photographers will not use a tripod, even though using one is fundamental to high quality images. Call it the, “I just like to walk around and shoot what I like without a lot of heavy stuff to contend with” compulsion that 99% of camera users follow; and I am one of them. It is my worst fault.

So, as I began my journey to Ecuador, I took the time to visit South Beach in Miami while awaiting an afternoon flight. And it was fun walking around shooting stuff without a lot of gear in tow. Especially my 20-pound backpack.

img_0039.jpg

And while shooting, guess what, photography was fun again — the freedom just to walk around and record what I saw was easy to do and unobtrusive. The clear advantage was the flexibility of the zoom lens and the size of the camera. Most folks I encountered just considered me to be another tourist on vacation taking snapshots. And that was exactly what I was, just a guy on vacation having fun.

img_0056.jpg

And I found some interesting things to point the camera at. Like Bogie. I still think Bogie was the best actor there ever was, and I loved his style and attitude. Call me a Bogie wannabe.

img_0066.jpg

Seems that a distant relative of mine wound up living in Tanzania a long time ago. And, he had this boat. Turns out his boat was used in filming The African Queen. In my view, the greatest movie ever made, well, I sorta like High Noon too. Gary Cooper is my other hero.

But, I digress. So let’s get back to the G9. And, let’s look at some example photos taken from the perspective of a tourist on vacation. Like this shot taken at Punta Suarez in the Galapagos Islands. Just a street scene. Nothing more. I do like the colors though.

img_0793.jpg

Course, even tourists sometimes work hard to get that special shot to show grandma and the gals at the office what it was like in the Galapagos Islands, after all, going on vacation is about sharing stuff with others, even though most of the time others could care less, but it does the heart good to hear someone say, “Oh wow, you are so lucky to have gone there, someday I hope to get there too.” Even though they don’t ever ask you how much it cost.

img_0525.jpg

And of course, junior may just show the shot to his class when the teacher starts talking about environmental stuff. A shot perfect for talking about endangered species on “conservation day” at your son’s elementary school. “Gosh Jimmy, your dad took this shot? Way cool.”

Course Jimmy may not show his class this shot. It’s not the sort of thing that elementary kids care much about. But, then I have seen similar shots in magazines. Wish I knew one that would buy it. :-)

img_1176.jpg

Well, photography is about memories. It’s about capturing stuff we want to look at again and again. Especially when you get older and forget what it was like to roam the streets of Ecuador. Stuff like music I heard, especially that fantastic sound of the pan-flute. Awesome.

img_1169.jpg

Or even better, remembering a nice lady I met at a local market. Her eyes sorta tell the story of what it is like to travel. There are nice people everywhere.

img_1185.jpg

To summarize, I like the Canon Powershot G9 very much. It’s an outstanding camera. I look forward to using it constantly in the days ahead, especially when I get to Scotland in late March. Can’t wait to try doing some landscapes with it. Course, knowing me, I will still have my Canon 1Ds Mark II and my Canon 16-35mm f/2.8L with me, despite the weight, cause I know it will produce the best images I can do, if I take the time to get the exposure right and use a tripod. But, I still have high hopes for what Canon is doing and has done with the Canon Powershot G9. And I have some recommendations for Canon, most likely never to be consider by them, but here’s my list for the perfect camera:

1. Keep it small, the same size.

2. Put back the swivel LCD panel you had on the Canon Powershot G6 so that guys like me who are 6′ 2″ tall can do lower perspective shots without lying on the ground!

3. Do something about noise at higher ISOs. You guys are putting too many pixels in the wrong sized sensor.

4. Give me a better lens. In fact, give me the best lens you can produce and make it wider, say 16mm using the 35mm standard. Yep, wider.

5. Charge me a lot more money for it. I would be willing to pay say four or five times the price for better lenses and better resolution at higher ISOs.

6. Do something about the viewfinder. At least put something in the viewfinder that tells me what I am actually shooting. I don’t like composition using the LCD. It ain’t natural.

I’m not asking much.

In the meantime, I’ll be out shooting with my new Canon Powershot G9, looking for that special moment when the light dances. And, I will be looking at shots done with the same camera by a real professional photographer like my friend Darwin Wiggett. Gotta go buy some filters!

And, if I find some good stuff, I will post the shots on my website here, where larger versions of many of the shots shown in this blog are now.

11 Comments so far

  1. Michael Brown on February 8th, 2008

    Great stuff Bill!
    I am enjoying this, tagging along with you as you describe your trip to Galapagos.

    I was seriously thinking on purchasing a G9, and was curious as to what type of underwater housing you used with the G9?

    Michael

  2. bill on February 8th, 2008

    Hi Michael,

    I bought the Canon WP-DC21 underwater housing. While the housing is very well built, I had issues with focusing on subjects because one must look straight on at the LCD screen. While this works well with SCUBA gear it is problematic when snorkeling. As I do more SCUBA trips, I hope to get better photos. We will see.

    Bill

  3. Sue on February 9th, 2008

    Outstanding! I just bought a G9, and happened on your site tonight. I will be following this, and just wanted to say that I couldn’t agree more with your ‘wish list’ to Canon! The image of the lady in the market is superb - hard to believe it came from this little camera.

    Sue

  4. Big Mike on February 17th, 2008

    Those are some gorgeous photos. I just ordered a G9, I can’t wait to receive it.

  5. Neil on February 22nd, 2008

    Bill, great review. I am trying to weigh up getting a 400D or a G9, initially to wander around Delhi, Jaipur and Agra but also to use for those landscape shots in Ranthambur when the 5D has the 100-400 attached. What would you recommend Bill, the G9 does RAW so I am tempted in this direction. Of course your shots from this camera look good, doesn’t mean mine will ;)

    Cheers

    N

  6. bill on February 22nd, 2008

    Hi Neil,

    A choice between the 400D and the G9 is a tough one. The 400D will be the more expensive choice. If you already have a good wide-angle lens that you can mount on the 400D, it is more likely that you will get better results than what you can expect from the G9. I have the 10-22 EFs lens and I am getting excellent results on the 400D. On the other hand, the G9 is smaller, produces outstanding photographs, if you stay under ISO 200, is a cheaper alternative, and has the advantage of portability when carrying around another camera such as the 5D, 100-400mm, combination. Frankly, the 5D will produce far better landscapes than either the 400D or the G9. In sum, my first choice would be to shoot with the 5D and a good wide angle lens and force myself to change lenses when the subject of the photograph is different. I know, it’s a real pain to do that, and it has been my experience that the second I put on a wide angle lens, something happens in front of me that demands the need for a telephoto lens! This is not to say that the G9 is not an outstanding camera, it is. And, as I pointed out in my review, Darwin Wiggett, one of the best landscape photographers in the world today, routinely uses the G9 and reports that his stock photo agency is selling the shots. In sum, one of the most frustrating aspects of photography today is deciding what equipment to take on a journey. Increasingly I vote for equipment that is light weight and flexible. And I must admit that the G9 is simply a joy to use and has brought back fun to my photography. I am currently planning a journey to the Isle of Skye and the G9 will be with me along with my 1Ds II. But, there is no doubt in my mind, that my first choice will be to shoot with the 1Ds II because of it’s high resolution. That is why I think you need to consider using the 5D on your journey. It will produce photographs of much higher quality than either of the other two cameras.

    Bill

  7. [...] Bill Lockhart’s Blog » The Canon Powershot G9 - A User’s Review [...]

  8. Bryan on February 22nd, 2008

    Thanks for the review, Bill. I just bought a G9 myself (it’s currently at the post office waiting for me to pick it up :)) the same reason you did. My main reason though is to use it on a trip to Norway early this summer. Glad to hear that you’re having good luck with it and these kind of reviews, I’m sure, will help me avoid buyers remorse. Looking forward to giving this little camera a go.

  9. R.J. Haines on February 25th, 2008

    Thanx for the review Bill. It was very helpful in mellowing my anxiety. I had just ordered the G9 from Amazon today and your review confirmed my feelings about the decision. I already have a 5D, which is great, but I’ve really been feeling the need for a walking around camera. Very often I see images of people, places and things when I either don’t have my 5D with me and that would be fine in a smaller format anyway. With the inclusion of RAW, IS and 12.1 mpx as well as 6x optical it seems to be ideal for street photography. Walking around with the 5D with a flash for nite shots is a little rough on the arthritis. Hopefully the G9 will resolve that issue.

    Thanx again

  10. Don Saunders on February 28th, 2008

    I agree with your assessment of the G9. I also purchased a Lensmate (for using a polarizing filter and IR filter) and Custom Grip and Thumb Rest from LensMate. The grip really makes holding the G9 more comfortable! Here’s the link:
    http://www.lensmateonline.com/newsite/order_G7_1.html

    I enjoyed your review!

  11. Kelly on March 7th, 2008

    Awesome review!!
    Bill, your photos are given by the great reality.